Social Media and The Death of Expertise

In a world of increasing complexity, we can't afford to get any dumber.

Hi Friends 👋,

I was watching what should have been an absurd scene, a respected astronomer, their decades of research and observation reduced to a mere "perspective," forced to debate a flat Earth conspiracy theorist as if both viewpoints deserved equal consideration. The host, in what they surely thought was admirable fairness, insisted that the audience respect both sides equally. That their individual "expertise" held the same weight.

My stomach churned. This wasn't discourse, it was the death of expertise playing out in real time.

The COVID pandemic only reinforced this troubling reality. I watched in horror as social media platforms became battlegrounds where self-proclaimed experts, armed with nothing more than a few hastily read articles and watched YouTube videos, demanded the same respect as infectious disease doctors who had dedicated their entire lives to understanding and fighting diseases. These were professionals who had spent decades in labs, treated patients across the globe, and published peer-reviewed research. Yet somehow, in our modern discourse, their expertise was considered merely one "side" of the debate.

Climate change might be the most damning example of all. The evidence is literally burning around us, flooding our cities, and reshaping our coastlines. Yet we continue to give equal airtime to influencers and politicians who "don't believe in" climate change, as if belief has anything to do with scientific reality. We place their uninformed opinions on the same pedestal as climate scientists who have spent decades measuring atmospheric changes, analyzing data, and documenting the transformation of our planet.

The truly deceitful part of this false equivalence is how it actively discourages the pursuit of real expertise. Why spend years studying, researching, and gaining genuine experience when you can binge-watch some conspiracy videos and be granted the same platform, the same respect, the same weight in public discourse? We've created a perverse incentive system that rewards intellectual laziness and punishes rigorous study.

This isn't about creating echo chambers or shutting down dissent. Real experts, true scholars, actually crave legitimate opposition. They want their theories challenged, their methods questioned, their conclusions scrutinized. But they want this done with reverence for the scientific method, with respect for the craft of research, with the shared goal of advancing human knowledge. Instead, they're forced to engage with conspiracy theorists whose only goal is winning political points or gaining social media followers.

When I look to the future, I see dark clouds gathering. America's position as a world leader isn't guaranteed, it was built on innovation, expertise, and respect for intellectual achievement. As we continue to devalue these qualities, I see us sliding into a corporate feudalism, where our declining quality of life is matched only by our declining ability to understand why it's happening.

The solution starts with naming the problem, this "both sides" narrative is killing expertise. We must stop giving equal weight to unequal arguments. Most importantly, we need to return to a place where expertise is respected, where the hard work of learning is valued over the lazy shortcuts of "doing your own research" online.

If we don't, the dumbing down of America won't just continue, it will accelerate. And in a world of increasing complexity, we can't afford to get any dumber.

Much Love 💛

-jason